1. Home
  2. Templates
  3. Five-question filter

Idea validation checklist

The five-question filter

These are the five questions I run every candidate problem through before I build anything. You can answer them in an afternoon of thinking, not a month of research. Use the filter when you have a few problems in mind and need to find out which ones deserve your time.

Type straight into the sheet or print it blank. What you type stays in this browser and is never sent anywhere.

The Code Was Never the Hard Part

The five-question filter

One problem per sheet. Answer in one line each, in the words of the people who have it.

The problem

  1. Do the people who have it know they have it?

    If your first task is convincing them the problem is real, you start the race far behind.

  2. Are they already paying to cope with it?

    Tools, services, freelancers, their own hours. Existing spend proves the pain is real and budgeted.

  3. Can you reach them?

    Start with who they are. Then name the channel: where do they gather, what do they read, who do they listen to?

  4. Does the problem come back?

    A weekly problem is better than a yearly one, and a daily one is even better.

  5. Do you have an edge?

    Whatever others can't copy: your understanding, network, taste, distribution, credibility.

A problem doesn't need a perfect score. But a clear no on reach or on existing pain should kill the candidate on the spot.

neverthehardpart.com/templates/five-question-filter

How to use it

  1. Before you filter anything, write down which race you're running (a side product, a new venture, or a credibility play) and your real constraints: hours a week you can sustain, money you can lose without stress, months before you need to see a signal.
  2. Run problems you have actually observed through it, not ideas from a brainstorm. A problem exists whether or not you build anything, so it gives you something to study. One problem per sheet.
  3. Answer each question in one line, in the words of the people who have the problem.
  4. Kill any candidate with a clear no on reach or on existing pain. Ruling candidates out is what the filter is for.
  5. Take the survivors into real conversations. The conversation guide is the next step.

The five questions

1. Do the people who have it know they have it?

Products that solve problems people don't know they have are some of the hardest to sell, because education is the most expensive form of marketing there is. If your first task is convincing people the problem is real, you start the race far behind. Pick problems people already complain about in their own real words.

2. Are they already paying to cope with it?

Someone paying is the simplest and strongest signal in business. Not payment for your future product, but payment for anything that touches the problem today. Tools, services, freelancers, hours of their own time. Existing spend proves the pain is real and budgeted, and "we pay someone to do this manually every week" tells you far more than "this would be nice."

3. Can you reach them?

Sit down and answer, specifically: who are these people, where do they gather, what do they read, who do they listen to? Start with who, because the other answers depend on it. "Small business owners" doesn't point to any channel, but "hairdressers who run their own salon" does. If you can't name the channel, you don't have a distribution plan yet. A mediocre product with a clear path to its audience usually does better than a great product with no path. So I put distribution here, at the choosing stage, instead of leaving it for after launch.

4. Does the problem come back?

A problem people have once gives you customers once, and that's a hard business to run unless you are really good at charging for it. A problem that keeps coming back gives people a reason to return, and that's where trust and revenue build up. A weekly problem is better than a yearly one, and a daily one is even better.

5. Do you have an edge?

When building is cheap, anyone can copy your feature list in weeks. Your protection is whatever they can't copy: your understanding of the customer, your network in the industry, your taste, your distribution, your credibility. If you can't name your edge for this specific problem, someone with an edge will pass you.

And one question of my own

The filter is there to stop you from spending months on something nobody needs. It isn't there to talk you out of the idea you can't stop thinking about. There will be weeks when nothing works and nobody seems to care, and liking the work is what gets you through those. So next to the five, I'd ask one question of my own: does this give me energy? A problem that scores well and bores you is hard to keep going. One that scores so-so and that you keep coming back to can still be worth building.

Where question five caught me

Run the filter on Videofy, the video startup I co-founded, and the first four questions come back fine. The fifth doesn't. What we had against Instagram and YouTube was that we were early and we moved fast, but a head start like that runs out. When the giants turned their attention to video, they didn't copy us. They probably didn't even know we existed. They just took our users, our advertisers and our audience within a short time, and after that nobody needed us. An edge has to hold up when someone bigger starts working on the same problem.

From chapter 2, "Pick your race". For what comes after the filter, read How to validate an app idea before you build it.

Kindle ebook · Out now

Out now. Read it this weekend.

$9.99

Read it on a Kindle or in the free Kindle app on your phone, tablet or computer. The paperback comes later.